CureZone.com
  

   Home > Article Index > Antiphospholipid Syndrome > Articles

• Go Back

Reprinted from:
EducationGuardian.co.uk

Scientists are accepting large sums of money from drug companies

By Sarah Boseley, The Guardian


Scandal of scientists who take money for papers ghostwritten by drug companies.

Doctors named as authors may not have seen raw data

Sarah Boseley, health editor
Thursday February 7, 2002


The Guardian

Scientists are accepting large sums of money from drug companies to put their names to articles endorsing new medicines that they have not written - a growing practice that some fear is putting scientific integrity in jeopardy.

Ghostwriting has become widespread in such areas of medicine as cardiology and psychiatry, where drugs play a major role in treatment. Senior doctors, inevitably very busy, have become willing to "author" papers written for them by ghostwriters paid by drug companies.

Originally, ghostwriting was confined to medical journal supplements sponsored by the industry, but it can now be found in all the major journals in relevant fields. In some cases, it is alleged, the scientists named as authors will not have seen the raw data they are writing about - just tables compiled by company employees.

The doctors, who may also give a talk based on the paper to an audience of other doctors at a drug company-sponsored symposium, receive substantial sums of money. Fuller Torrey, executive director of the Stanley Foundation Research Programmes in Bethesda, Maryland, found in a survey that British psychiatrists were being paid around $2,000 (£1,400) a time for symposium talks, plus airfares and hotel accommodation, while Americans got about $3,000. Some payments ran as high as $5,000 or $10,000.

"Some of us believe that the present system is approaching a high-class form of professional prostitution," he said.

Robin Murray, head of the division of psychological medicine at the Institute of Psychiatry in London, is one of those who has become increasingly concerned. "It is clear that we have a situation where, when an audience is listening to a well-known British psychiatrist, you recognise the stage where the audience is uncertain as to whether the psychiatrist really believes this or is saying it because they them selves or their department is getting some financial reward," he said.

"I can think of a well-known British psychiatrist I met and I said, ´How are you?´ He said, ´What day is it? I´m just working out what drug I´m supporting today.´"

Marcia Angell, former editor of the New England Journal of Medicine, wrote a year ago that when she ran a paper on antidepressant drug treatment, the authors´ financial ties to the manufacturers - which the journal requires all contributors to declare - were so extensive that she had to run them on the website. She decided to commission an editorial about it and spoke to research psychiatrists, but "we found very few who did not have financial ties to drug companies that make antidepressants."

She wrote: "Researchers serve as consultants to companies whose products they are studying, join advisory boards and speakers´ bureaus, enter into patent and royalty arrangements, agree to be the listed authors of articles ghostwritten by interested companies, promote drugs and devices at company-sponsored symposiums, and allow themselves to be plied with expensive gifts and trips to luxurious settings. Many also have equity interest in the companies."

In September her journal joined the Lancet and 11 others in denouncing the drug companies for imposing restrictions on the data to which scientists are given access in the clinical trials they fund. Some of the journals propose to demand a signed declaration that the papers scientists submit are their own.

The success of Prozac, the antidepressant which became a cult "happy" drug in the 1990s, substantially raised the stakes in psychiatry. Its promotion coincided with the decline of state funding for research, leaving scientists in all areas of medicine dependent on pharmaceutical companies to fund or commission their work. That in turn gave the industry unprecedented control over data and ended with research papers increasingly being drafted by company employees or commercial agencies.

The responsibility of scientists for the content of their papers takes on serious significance in the context of court cases in the US, where relatives of people who killed themselves and murdered others while on SSRIs (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors) - the class of drug to which Prozac belongs - claimed the drugs were responsible. According to David Healy, a north Wales-based psychopharmacologist who has given evidence for the families, the companies have relied on articles apparently authored by scientists who may in fact have not seen the raw data.

Dr Healy, who had unprecedented access to the data that the companies keep in their archives, said: "It may well be that 50% of the articles on drugs in the major journals across all areas of medicine are not written in a way that the average person in the street expects them to be authored."

He cites the case brought last year against the former SmithKline Beecham (now GlaxoSmithKline) by relatives of Donald Schell. The court found that the company´s best-selling antidepressant, an SSRI called Seroxat, had caused Schell to murder his wife, daughter and granddaughter and commit suicide.

The company´s defence was based on scientific papers which analysed the results of trials comparing Seroxat with a placebo and found there was no increased risk of suicide for depressed people on Seroxat. But the raw data probably does not support that, argues Dr Healy. Some of the placebo suicides took place while patients were withdrawing from an older drug. When the figures are readjusted without these, he says, they show there is substantially increased risk of suicide on Seroxat.

This raises the question of whether the eminent scientists whose names were on the papers ever saw the raw data from the trials - or saw only tables compiled by company employees, he says. David Dunner, a professor at the University of Washington, who co-authored one of the papers in 1995, admits he did not see the raw data. "I don´t know who saw it. I did not," he said. "My role in the paper was that the data were presented to us and we analysed it and wrote it up and wrote references."

His co-author Stuart Montgomery, then of St Mary´s hospital medical school in London, declined to answer calls and emails from the Guardian. The third name on the paper is that of Geoff Dunbar, a company employee.

The World Health Organisation has expressed concern about the ties between industry and researchers. Jonathan Quick, director of essential drugs and medicines policy, wrote in the latest WHO Bulletin: "If clinical trials become a commercial venture in which self-interest overrules public interest and desire overrules science, then the social contract which allows research on human subjects in return for medical advances is broken."


EducationGuardian.co.uk © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2002

Reprinted from:
EducationGuardian.co.uk


Related:


    News

  1. Homeopathy, Economics, and Government  Aug 23
  2. Raw Milk Vs. Pasteurized Milk  Jun 06
  3. SARS ANTHRAX WEST NILE SMALLPOX FLU AIDS THE COMMON COLD  May 04
  4. Mercury fillings may be affecting dentists - study  Apr 19
  5. How I treated myself for Amalgam Illness  Apr 18
  6. The Most Interesting Stories from CureZone  Apr 18
  7. The Bowen Technique  Apr 18
  8. _BOB's Quick Cleanse  Apr 18
  9. Parasites? Me? Are you Kidding?  Apr 18
  10. Liver Flush - Quackery or Valuable Remedy  Apr 18
  11. Robert C. Atkins, M.D. Dies at 72  Apr 18
  12. Why You Don’t Want to Drink Pasteurized Milk  Mar 30
  13. Fish Farms Become Feedlots of the Sea  Dec 28
  14. What is Maggot Therapy?  Nov 22
  15. The Grisanti Report  Aug 30
  16. MAGNESIUM DEFICIENCY & SUDDEN DEATH  Aug 30
  17. Autism 'Linked to Mercury Vaccine'  Aug 16
  18. Autism and Mercury  Aug 16
  19. Death By Lethal Vaccine Injection  Aug 09
  20. Conventional vs. Alternative Medicine  Aug 06
  21. When Healing Becomes a Crime  Jul 29
  22. The cruelty of sucking gallbladder juice (bile) from live bears in China  Jul 23
  23. Bear's Bile - Big Business that may save bears  Jul 23
  24. Tibetan Herbal Medicine, Interview with Dr. Sonam Wangdu Changbhar  Jul 23
  25. Agreement reached to phase out bear farming in China  Jul 23
  26. China's bile bears finding sanctuary  Jul 23
  27. This is what you will bring into your life  May 29
  28. 12 Plants that have no purpose  May 26
  29. Pesticides and the Immune System: The Public Health Risks  May 23
  30. Caffeine, even in small doses, may hurt arteries  May 18
  31. Mother’s love “helps keep kids off drugs”   May 18
  32. POISON FOR PROFIT - WHAT A BUSINESS PLAN!  May 16
  33. The Truth is Out There   May 16
  34. Moving Toward a Cashless Society  May 16
  35. Do Killer Microbes Cause Breast Cancer?  May 15
  36. Why Do Pharmaceutical Drugs Injure and Kill?  May 15
  37. Are Vaccines Causing More Disease Than They are Curing?  May 15
  38. HEALTHY WEB LINKS  May 03
  39. COLORADO bill to add Hepatitis A Vaccine  May 02
  40. Crib Death - Infection May Cause SIDS  May 02
  41. Exercise Can Lower Risk of Death from Stroke  May 01
  42. Safety of New Drugs Cannot Be Known for Many Years  May 01
  43. Mercury fillings are affecting dentists  May 01
  44. Biological clock starts ticking in late 20s: study  Apr 30
  45. Ulcer surgery linked to risk of pancreatic cancer  Apr 30
  46. British group says patients can refuse treatment  Apr 30
  47. Vegetarians Face Child Abuse Charge  Apr 30
  48. The Signs of Inner Peace  Apr 30
  49. WHO announces urgent meeting on new food cancer scare  Apr 29
  50. A Simple Guide To Herbs  Apr 26
  51. Diet, Aging, and Muscle by Joe Friel  Apr 26

Back To Top



 

Donate to CureZone

 


Share:  Facebook  MySpace  Digg  Reddit  StumbleUpon  Furl this page  Delicious  BlinkList  dzone  Simpy.com  Fark.com  BlogMarks  Wists.com  Google

Translate This Page:

French    German    Spain    Italian    Dutch    Russian    Portuguese    Japanese    Korean    Arabic    Chinese Simplified




 
Google Ads



 
Medianet Ads
Back To Top

Selected Ads from CureZone Sponsors: Become a Sponsor

VIP

Oxy-Powder® Official
Refresh & Detoxify Your Body Fast. Free Shipping On Orders. Buy Now!
I regained my life!
I no longer worry about having Herpes outbreaks
Heal Type 2 Diabetes
Simple, 3-step natural approach heals diabetes within a month. No side e...
 
 

PLAT

Oxy-Powder® Colon Cleanse
All Natural Oxygen Cleanser. Rated Best Product Line by NaturalNews...
Clarkia Extra Strong
Clarkia Tincture 2 oz, 4 oz, 8 oz, and 16 oz
Free Clark DVD!
Bestselling author Dr. Hulda Clark claims to have cured cancer
Natural Cancer Remedies
 
 

GOLD

Proven medical anti-diabetic benefits
Electrolyzed drinking water significantly reduces blood...
Proven Candida & Parasite Treatment
The Only Legitimate Natural Treatment for Eliminating Can...
Utopia Silver Supplements
Silver Bulletin e-News Magazine, ”What the Coming Food Collapse Mea...
Destroy Parasites Quickly
Learn How to Destroy Parasites And Be Free of Your Unbearable Sympt...
 
 

GOLD

The Ultimate Lemonade Cleanse
For the first time ever, we have created a complete Lemonade Cl...
Detoxify and Cleanse Naturally
Drink ionized alkaline waters medically proven health benefits...
Dr. Clark: Best Prices You Will Find!
Tools for Healing is the number one source for products...
Natural Health Product
For candida, arthritis, immune system
 
 

SILVER

Lugol’s Iodine Free S&H
J.Crow’s® Lugol’s Iodine Solution. Restore lost reserves.
Best Candida Treatment
Get rid of chronic Candida.Works fast.Guaranteed Results!
The Tesla Shield™
Transformational Technology For Mind Body And Soul.
The Best Years in Life
Naturally live longer, healthier and happier and avoid mainstream mana...
 
 
Back To Top How many people click on the sponsord links? Become a Sponsor



 


Guest Book - Liver Flush FAQ - News - Link Exchange - Add URL - How To Exchange Links? - About Global Directory

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Spam Policy - Disclaimer - Guidelines & Rules - Forum Trolls - Fair use notice

Staff's pages:  Owen - Wrenn - Maya


CureZone Newsletter is distributed in partnership with www.netatlantic.com


Contact Us - About - Donors - Stats



Copyright 2014  curezone.com


fetched in 0.14 sec at 8/1/2014 9:00:45 AM, requested by 54.82.22.63, referred by http://curezone.com/art/read.asp?ID=118&db=1&C0=1 , requested 1 pages during this session, y=3