CureZone
  All Blogs
    Mother Earth Heals

Blog: Mother Earth Heals
by Liora Leah

684 blog entries; 17 entries per page; 1 pages; viewed 1,679,589 times
Description   |   Rules   |   Disclaimer

ADVERTISEMENTS
 
Medianet Ads



ADVERTISEMENTS
 

Eliminate Herpes
Information on the revolutionary Dynamiclear Combat Kit - External & Inter...


Reverse Type 2 Diabetes
Learn The Real Cause Type 2 Diabetes…And How To Turn It On Its Head...


Kidney Stones Remedy
Hulda Clark Cleanses


Skin Therapy Soaps
Silver Aloe-Aloe Gold-Copper Aloe Skin Therapy Soap. All Natural with pl...


Good Health Naturally
The best in digestive enzymes, serrapeptase, krill oil, olive leaf ex...




ADVERTISEMENTS
 
Ads from CureZone Sponsors

Eliminate Herpes
Information on the revolutionary Dynamiclear Combat Kit


All Natural Colon Cleanse
Refresh & Detoxify Your Body Fast. Clean Your Colon The Healthy W...


___________

Clove Parasite Cleanse
Hulda Clark Cleanses


Natural Cancer Remedies


Safest Colon Cleanse
All Natural, Clinically Tested Colon Cleanse. 180-Day Money Back Guara...


___________

Proven Candida Diet
The Only Legitimate Diet for Treating Candida in 30 Days


Destroy Parasites Naturally
Destroy Parasites Permanently in 30 Days or Less


Proven medical anti-diabetic benefits
Electrolyzed drinking water significantly reduces blo...


Detoxify and Cleanse Naturally
Drink ionized alkaline waters medically proven health benefi...


Pine Cone Extract
Have a yeast infection? Try Immunophen, a dietary supplement designed to ...


Get 5% off Right Now!
Get 5% off anything in our homeopathic health store using the coupon ...


___________

Best Candida Treatment
Ccws™ Works Fast To Get Rid Of Candida.Feel Healthy.Money Back Guara...


The Krill Miracle™
Concentrated Omega 3, 6 & 9, Many Times More Powerful than Fish Oil


J.Crow’s® Lugol’s Iodine
Free S&H. Restore lost reserves. J.CROW’S® Lugol’s Iodine Solu...


Become a Sponsor

Dolphin Deaths Due to BP Oil Spill

April 20 marks the second anniversary of the BP oil spill. The numbers of whales and dolphins killed in BP's Deepwater Horizon disaster could be 50 times higher than the number of carcasses found.


Date:   4/18/2012 7:49:57 PM   ( 28 mon ) ... viewed 10216 times

Did BP Spill Kill Hundreds More Dolphins?

| Tue Mar. 29, 2011 10:32 PM PDT

Killer whales. Photo by Pittman, courtesy NOAA, via Wikimedia Commons.

Killer whales. Photo by Pittman, courtesy NOAA, via Wikimedia Commons.

A new paper in Conservation Letters calculates that the numbers of whales and dolphins killed in BP's Deepwater Horizon disaster could be 50 times higher than the number of carcasses found.

The authors—a high-powered list of renowned cetacean researchers from Canada, the US, Australia, and Scotland (including Scott Krause, who I filmed years ago for a documentary about North Atlantic right whales)—write of a general misperception of the Deepwater Horizon impact:

Many media reports have suggested that the spill caused only modest environmental impacts, in part because of a low number of observed wildlife mortalities, especially marine mammals.

Atlantic spotted dolphins. Photo by Bmatulis, via Wikimedia Commons.

Atlantic spotted dolphins. Photo by Bmatulis, via Wikimedia Commons.

Compared to the 1989 Exxon Valdez, with its iconic oiled otters and high body counts, the Deepwater Horizon seems, well, not so bad. The authors point out that "only" 101 dead cetaceans (whales, dolphins, and porpoises) were found in the Northern Gulf of Mexico as of 7 November 2010. The number's misleading though.

The issue arises when policymakers, legislators, or biologists treat these carcass-recovery counts as though they were complete counts or parameters estimated from some representative sample, when in fact, they are opportunistic observations. Our study suggests that these opportunistic observations should be taken to estimate only the bare minimum number of human-caused mortalities.

Humpback whale. Photo by Whit Welles Wwelles14, via Wikimedia Commons.

Humpback whale. Photo by Whit Welles Wwelles14, via Wikimedia Commons.

So how many more whales, dolphins, and porpoises actually died? That problem is tough to figure to begin with and is compounded by a dearth of data in the Gulf—a fact that will work greatly in BP's favor when the time comes to levy fines.

The Gulf of Mexico is a semi-enclosed subtropical sea that forms essentially one ecosystem with many demographically independent cetacean populations. Some of these cetacean populations, such as killer whales (Orcinus orca), false killer whales (Pseudorca crassidens), melonheaded whales (Peponocephala electra), and several beaked whale species, appear to be quite small, are poorly studied, or are found in the pelagic realm where they could have been exposed to oil and yet never strand. Small, genetically isolated populations of bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) could have experienced substantial losses either inshore or offshore.

Atlantic spotted dolphins. Photo by Bmatulis, via Wikimedia Commons.

Atlantic spotted dolphins. Photo by Bmatulis, via Wikimedia Commons.

Two methods of extrapolation could shed light on how many cetaceans BP's disaster killed:

  1. Compare abundance before the disaster to abundance after—but since we don't know the population size of whale and dolphins species in the Gulf before hand we're unlikely to notice anything short of "the most catastrophic decline" and maybe not even that.
  2. Count the number of carcasses recovered—knowing that many will evade our count, having sunk, decayed, been scavenged, or drifted away. So adjust the counts upward to estimate total mortality. This approach is used to estimate bird deaths at power lines, where, in at least one instance, we now know that bird body counts underestimate total actual deaths by a whopping 32 percent.

The authors worked the two methods as best they could and added something more.

Given the magnitude of the spill and complexity of the response, quantifying the ecological impacts will take a long time. To contribute to this effort, we examined historical data from the Northern Gulf of Mexico to evaluate whether cetacean carcass counts in this region have previously been reliable indicators of mortality, and may therefore accurately represent deaths caused by the Deepwater Horizon/BP event.

Sperm whale. Photo courtesy NOAA, via Wikimedia Commons.

Sperm whale. Photo courtesy NOAA, via Wikimedia Commons.

Their methods and analysis suggest that an average of 4,474 cetaceans died in the northern Gulf every year between 2003 and 2007 from all causes, human and natural. Yet since an average of only 17 bodies were found in those years, the body count represented only ~0.4 percent of total deaths.

Consider, for example, one sperm whale being detected as a carcass, and a necropsy identified oiling as a contributing factor in the whale's death. If the carcass-detection rate for sperm whales is 3.4%, then it is plausible that 29 sperm whale deaths represents the best estimate of total mortality, given no additional information. If, for example, 101 cetacean carcasses were recovered overall, and all deaths were attributed to oiling, the average-recovery rate (2%) would translate to 5,050 carcasses, given the 101 carcasses detected.

Those are chilling numbers. Period. But also in light of the relatively tiny populations of cetaceans in the Gulf. Especially since most if not all cetaceans are highly social, and since oil and chemical dispersants likely injured, sickened, or killed entire clusters, schools, pods, matrilines, or groups at the same time—and may still be doing so.

The authors describe the near-lethal affect of the Exxon Valdez disaster on one well-known and well-studied pod of killer whales in Alaska.

In the first year after the 1989 Exxon Valdez spill, the AT1 group of "transient" killer whales experienced a 41% loss; there has been no reproduction since the spill. Although the cause of the apparent sterility is unknown, the lesson serves as an important reminder that immediate death is not the only factor that can lead to long-term loss of population viability.

Pilot whale mother and calf. Photo by Clark Anderson via Wikimedia Commons.

Pilot whale mother and calf. Photo by Clark Anderson via Wikimedia Commons.

The paper:

  • Williams. R, Gero. S, Bejder. L., Calambokidis. J, Kraus. S, Lusseau. D, Read. A, Robbins. J. Underestimating the Damage: Interpreting Cetacean Carcass Recoveries in the Context of the Deepwater Horizon/BP Incident. Conservation Letters. Wiley-Blackwell. March 2011, DOI: 10.1111/j.1755-263X.2011.00168.x

Crossposted from Deep Blue Home.

 
 
 

Julia Whitty

Environmental Correspondent

Julia Whitty is the environmental correspondent for Mother Jones. Her latest book is Deep Blue Home: An Intimate Ecology of Our Wild Ocean. For more of her stories, click here. RSS |

 

Add This Entry To Your CureZone Favorites!

Printer-friendly version of this page
Email this message to a friend
Bookmark this page/Add to Favorites or press Ctrl+D
DISCLAIMER / WARNING   Alert Webmaster



Share:  Facebook  MySpace  Digg  Reddit  StumbleUpon  Furl this page  Delicious  BlinkList  dzone  Simpy.com  Fark.com  BlogMarks  Wists.com  Google

Add This Blog To Your CureZone Favorites!
 
Add This Entry To Your CureZone Favorites!

Comments (25 of 479):
Re: Organic Batter… Liora… 43 d
Re: Organic Batter… Desti… 43 d
Re: Chemicals Maki… Liora… 7 mon
Re: Chemicals Maki… zincs… 14 mon
Re: Photos:Human C… Liora… 18 mon
Re: Photos:Human C… Milla… 18 mon
Re: Photos:Human C… Liora… 18 mon
Re: Environmental … Liora… 28 mon
Re: Environmental … Liora… 28 mon
Re: Environmental … mu-sh… 28 mon
Re:1 million page … Liora… 30 mon
Re:1 million page … YOURE… 30 mon
Re: Occupy Tokyo--… YOURE… 31 mon
Re: What are you B… Liora… 32 mon
What are you BEING? Liora… 32 mon
Re: No More Corpo… ruden… 33 mon
Re: This is, I sup… Liora… 3 y
This is, I suppose… mu-sh… 3 y
oops!Sorry!Mistake! Liora… 3 y
Re: Styrofoam Alt… Liora… 3 y
Re: Styrofoam Alt… Liora… 3 y
Re: Styrofoam Alt… ren 3 y
Re: Thank you for … YOURE… 3 y
Re: Sungazing/Bare… Liora… 3 y
Re: Sungazing/Bare… lovel… 3 y
All Comments (479)

Blog Entries (12 of 684):
Dolphin Deaths Due to BP Oil…  28 mon
Peru Bans GMO's!  28 mon
Millions Against Monsanto  28 mon
Fukushima Remembered  29 mon
SAVE CHILDREN! Kony 2012  29 mon
Earth Is Alive!  29 mon
ShutDown Nuke Power!  30 mon
Wild Farming!  30 mon
Bottles Houses!  30 mon
Truth About Nuclear Power  30 mon
Poisoned Eagle Released  30 mon
S.Cal Nuke Plant Leaks  30 mon
All Entries (684)

Blogs by Liora Leah (1):
Spirit Speaks  31 mon  (256)

Similar Blogs (10 of 185):
Plant Your Dream!  by YourEnchantedGardener  20 h
EarthSpirit  by Mayah  4 d
coconut oil detox  by jutzychan  8 d
Ya’ think??  by kerminator  9 d
Water Fasting  by lexg  13 d
ShinyLife  by Sacristia  16 d
Health in Your Hands  by curisto  17 d
Water Fasting refee…  by joiejoy  20 d
Psyche & Health  by Chef JeM  24 d
Cheeta: Cultural He…  by Chef JeM  29 d
All Blogs (1,019)


Liver Cleanse
Hulda Clark Liver Cleanse


Skin Therapy Soaps
Silver Aloe-Aloe Gold-Copper Aloe Skin Therapy Soap. All Natural with pl...


Good Health Naturally
The best in digestive enzymes, serrapeptase, krill oil, olive leaf ex...

Back To Top

Selected Ads from CureZone Sponsors: Become a Sponsor

VIP

Easy 4 Day Cleanse
Try This All-Natural, Clinically Tested Cleanse! Detox Your Body In A Few ...
Herpes Treatment News
World-First Single Application Herpes Treatment.
Faster, Easier and H...
Heal Type 2 Diabetes
Discover The Real Cause Type 2 Diabetes…And How To Turn It On Its Head I...
 
 

PLAT

Safest Colon Cleanse
All Natural, Clinically Tested Colon Cleanse. 180-Day Money Back Guarant...
Epsom Salt Encapsulated
Hulda Clark Cleanse Kits
Clark Bowel Cleanse
Dr. Hulda Clark’s Bowel Program (Intestinal Cleanse). Pure products! Grea...
Natural Cancer Remedies
 
 

GOLD

Alkaline Water Benefits?
Can you get health benefits from drinking alkaline ionized water? Wh...
Proven Candida Diet
The Only Legitimate Diet for Treating Candida in 30 Days
Utopia Silver Supplements
Colloidal Silver Testimonials. Read comments and opinions by users ...
Destroy Parasites Quickly
Learn How to Destroy Parasites And Be Free of Your Unbearable Sympt...
 
 

GOLD

Hydrazine Sulfate - Cancer Support
Hydrazine Sulfate’s Original Proponent, Dr. Joseph Gold Of...
Scientist prove anti-diabetic benefits
Electrolyzed drinking water significantly reduces bloo...
Healthy Weight Loss
”I saw results almost immediately, losing 52 pounds between September and...
Immunophen™
Discover how pine cone extract can assist your immune system to help control yeas...
 
 

SILVER

Lugol’s Iodine Free S&H
J.Crow’s® Lugol’s Iodine Solution. Restore lost reserves.
Best Candida Treatment
Ccws™ Works Fast To Get Rid Of Candida.Feel Healthy.Money Back Guarant...
The Tesla Shield™
Transformational Technology For Mind Body And Soul.
Native Remedies - People & Pets
Extensive line of herbal and homeopathic remedies for people ...
 
 
Back To Top How many people click on the sponsord links? Become a Sponsor



 


Guest Book - Liver Flush FAQ - News - Link Exchange - Add URL - How To Exchange Links? - About Global Directory

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Spam Policy - Disclaimer - Guidelines & Rules - Forum Trolls - Fair use notice

Staff's pages:  Owen - Wrenn - Maya


CureZone Newsletter is distributed in partnership with www.netatlantic.com


Contact Us - About - Donors - Stats



Copyright 2014  curezone.com


fetched in 0.39 sec at 8/22/2014 6:48:43 AM, requested by 54.83.229.255, referred by http://curezone.com/blogs/fm.asp?i=1930823 , requested 1 pages during this session, y=2