En excerpt from the book :
"ALTERNATIVES
IN CANCER THERAPY"
by Ross, R.Ph. Pelton, Lee Overholser
Amazon
Price: $10.40
New from $8.95
Used from $1.95
Beta-Carotene
FROM CANTALOUPES to broccoli and carrots to zucchini, when
your mother urged you to eat your fruits and vegetables, she was really helping
to protect you from cancer. Beta-carotene, a nutrient that occurs naturally in
many fruits and vegetables, is rapidly gaining recognition as an important
nutrient in the prevention and treatment of cancer.
Background
Cancer of the epithelial cells accounts for nearly 90 percent
of all cancers. The epithelial cells make up the skin, the lining of the
intestines, and other thin tissues throughout the body. Some of the studies in
this chapter show that beta-carotene helps to prevent cellular mutation and
cancer formation while at the same time strengthening the immune system. The
evidence comes from a number of sources, including cell culture studies, animal
model systems, and, more recently, human population studies.
Responsible treatment of cancer is more than a matter of
removing the current cancerous cells. Preventing a recurrence of the cancer is
just as important, and beta-carotene appears to be an important nutrient in this
effort.
Beta-carotene, like most of the substances used in alternative
cancer therapies, occurs naturally. It's also one of nature's immune-system
boosters and part of the protective anticancer systerns that are naturally found
in plants, animals, and humans.
An important principle of many alternative approaches to
cancer is that there is not much difference between treatment and prevention.
This principle also applies to preventing the reappearance of a treated cancer.
One researcher suggested, in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
that beta-carotene should be studied for its ability to prevent a recurrence of
primary tumors in patients who have been cured of their initial cancer, but have
an increased risk of developing new cancers. (29)
Beta-Carotene and Vitamin A
Vitamin A and beta-carotene arc chemically related. All the
vitamin A in our diets comes from animal sources, and all the beta-carotene
comes from fruits and vegetables. Beta-carotene, which is also called provitamin
A, is really just two molecules of vitamin A linked together. Whenever the body
needs more vitamin A, intestinal enzymes split a molecule of beta-carotene in
half. (9)
Chemically, vitamin A is called retinol, and its many analogs
are called retinoids. Beta-carotene is the most important carot-enoid, since it
is found in abundance in so many vegetables and has the highest level of
biological activity.
A large body of evidence suggests that both carotenoids and
retinoids play an important role in the prevention and treatment of cancer.
Several published studies provide comprehensive reviews of this research. (10,
14, 30) Much of the interest in these compounds stemmed from the knowledge that
vitamin A exerts profound effects on the healthy development of epithelial
tissues, helping to prevent cancers of the skin, mouth, esophagus, stomach,
lungs, mammary glands, cervix, bladder, colon, rectum, et cetera. (22)
The idea that retinoids and carotenoids could be used to
prevent cancer dates back to 1922, when it was reported that a deficiency of
vitamin A led to precancerous changes in epithelial cells of the respiratory
tract. (18) Solid evidence linking retinoids and cancer was published in 1926,
when Japanese researchers observed the development of stomach cancer in rats fed
diets deficient in vitamin A. (6)
Animal Studies
In the 1960s Drs. Leonida Santamaria and Amalia Bianchi
concluded that a number of studies demonstrated vitamin A's ability to prevent
cancer in cell and organ cultures, as well as in various chemically induced
tumors in animals. (24) Many subsequent studies have shown that when
beta-carotene is administered on the skin, injected, or added to the diet of
laboratory animals, it is capable of inhibiting various types of experimentally
induced cancers. (12) In 1977, in a study with animals prone to develop tumors,
it was shown for the first time that beta-carotene is capable of significantly
delaying the appearance of tumors and also reducing tumor growth rate. (5)
Another study assessed the effect of antioxidant nutrients
on chemically induced liver tumors. Vitamin E caused a 60-percent reduction
in the appearance of tumors. Glutathione caused an 80-percent reduction. Vitamin
C, selenium, and uric acid each individually caused an 87-percent reduction in
the appearance of liver tumors. However, the most impressive result was that
beta-carotene TOTALLY inhibited the development of liver tumors. (19)
In 1982 a study demonstrated that beta-carotene has anti-tumor
action in animals with transplanted tumors. Beta-carotene decreased tumor growth
and extended animal survival time; in addition, when beta-carotene was fed to
animals that had already developed palpable tumors, it slowed tumor growth and
increased animal survival time. (23)
Trials in Humans
The Basel study (1971-73) was one of the first large-scale
trials that showed the relationship between beta-carotene and cancer in humans.
(27) During the twelve-year follow-up, cancer mortality was highest in subjects
with the lowest plasma levels of beta-carotene. The plasma concentration of
beta-carotene was significantly lower in people who developed lung cancer and
stomach cancer, and for all cancer cases combined. (28) Many other studies have
been published since, which consistently show decreased rate of cancer in
subjects with high levels of beta-carotene. (16, 32)
Dietary Studies
Fill up your plate with those green and yellow fruits and
vegetables. Over twenty studies have been published showing a diet high in
vitamin A and carotenes lowers the risk of cancer. A study conducted at Harvard
University found that elderly individuals who reported the highest consumption
of green and yellow fruits and vegetables had a significantly decreased risk of
developing cancer. (4)
A large Japanese study showed that vegetable eaters had a
decreased risk of developing lung and stomach cancer. This twenty-year ongoing
study also indicates that damage from poor dietary and life-style habits is
reversible. For example, ex-smokers who ate a daily dose of vegetables reduced
their risk of lung cancer. Also, just eating more vegetables produced a
25-percent reduction in stomach cancer. (25)
Premalignant Lesions
Premalignant lesions are areas of abnormally developed cells
that are statistically known to be associated with the eventual development of
cancer. The most commonly occurring sites for pre-malignant lesions include the
skin, stomach, esophagus, cervix, oral cavity, lungs, bladder, and colon. .
The study of premalignant lesions offers an ideal opportunity
to identify and evaluate substances that actually inhibit the development of
cancer. Studies of premalignant lesions are limited in number, but cervical
dysplasia and oral leukoplakia are two types of precancerous lesions that have
been well researched.
PRECANCEROUS LESIONS OF THE MOUTH
Millions of people throughout the world indulge in the daily
habit of chewing either tobacco or betel nut leaves. These people frequently
develop precancerous cells in the skin that lines the mouth. (29) This condition
is called oral leukoplakia and is characterized by persistent white spots or
areas inside the mouth.
Some studies have shown that the consumption of foods rich in
beta-carotene reduces the risk of developing this type of oral cancer. (7, 15)
Other studies have shown that supplementation with beta-carotene has produced
complete or partial regression of this precancerous condition in the oral
cavity. (8)
THE CERVICAL CANCER LINK
Cervical dysplasia is a premalignant lesion of the uterine
cervix. It has been repeatedly shown that women with cervical dysplasia have a
significantly higher probability of developing cervical cancer. (26) Ten
different studies have been published showing that women with low dietary
intakes and/or low blood levels of beta-carotene have significantly increased
risks of cervical dysplasia and cancer of the cervix.
One of these studies reported that women consuming
beta-carotene in amounts below the study's median intake had a risk two to three
times greater of developing cervical dysplasia or localized cervical cancer than
women with the highest dietary beta-carotene intake. (31) In another study,
women with the highest plasma beta-carotene levels had approximately an
80-percent reduction in the risk of developing cervical cancer. (1)
Lung Cancer
One of the most consistent findings in nutritional research
has been the association between beta-carotene and reduced risk of lung
cancer—particularly, the reduced risk of squamous cell carcinoma. (17) Bronchial
metaplasia is a premalignant lesion that is considered to be an indicator of
risk for lung cancer in smokers.
The Immune Systemm] Recent
studies have begun to explore how vitamin A and beta-, carotenes inhibit cancer.
Their effect on the immune system in ;animals has been well known, but more
recently there have been studies on how they affect cells in the human immune
system. (21) Vitamin A compounds produce increases in T-helper s cells, whereas
beta-carotene produces significant increases in natural killer (NK) cells.
I Both nutrients also produce modest increases in other
cellular ¦markers in the immune system. Both retinoids and carotenoids ¦can
produce major changes in the human immune system at doses that are appropriate
to take as daily nutritional supplements. (33)
Beta-Carotene: A Powerful Antioxidant
Earlier anticancer studies tended to focus on vitamin A, but
recent evidence indicates that beta-carotene is a more powerful anti-cancer
agent. This stems from the discovery that beta-carotene is a powerful
antioxidant nutrient capable of neutralizing potential cancer-causing free
radicals. (2,11) It has been well established that free-radical damage to DNA
and cellular membranes can lead to cancer. (3)
Although vitamin A is an important essential nutrient, it does
not possess the same antioxidant, anticancer properties that beta-carotene does.
Since the body converts beta-carotene into vitamin A as needed, taking
beta-carotene provides the body with its vitamin A while providing an extra
level of antioxidant cancer prevention.
In 1981 research was published that proposed it was
beta-carotene and not dietary vitamin A that was responsible for significantly
reducing the risk of lung cancer in humans in previous studies. (20) This claim
stimulated research on beta-carotene and other carotenoids as possible
diet-related antitumor agents. /
Beta-Carotene: An Unusual Antioxidant
By the mid-1980s it was established that beta-carotene is an
unusual and previously unknown type of antioxidant. It is capable of
deactivating two of the most damaging types of unstable cancer-causing free
radicals, polyunsaturated fatty-acid radicals and the singlet-oxygen free
radical. The toxicity of oxygen free radicals is known to be a primary factor in
the initiation phase of cancer. (2)
The singlet-oxygen free radical is one of the most damaging
types of oxygen radicals. It is formed during regular metabolic processes, and
also as a result of exposure to direct sunlight (ultraviolet rays) or ozone.
Our bodies have developed enzymes to deal with most free
radicals, but we have not developed an enzyme system to neutralize the
singlet-oxygen radical. Beta-carotene is important because it is the only known
substance that can neutralize the singlet-oxygen radical. (13)
Preventing a Second Primary Malignancy
Tumor metabolism generates tremendous amounts of oxygen free
radicals. Two Italian physicians, Leonida Santamaria and Amalia Bianchi,
theorized that complete removal of a tumor with no lymph node involvement or
even successful removal of a tumor and all cancerous lymph nodes cannot reverse
or prevent change in the remaining epithelial tissue. The cells in the remaining
tissue may already have undergone free-radical-induced genetic change, which can
enable a second primary malignancy b grow in the same site. (24)
The expression "we got it all," after successful cancer
surgery, pay not accurately describe the situation. Prevention of further change
is as important as eliminating the existing cancer cells.
First Clinical Case Report [ 4980-88}
Drs. Santamaria and Bianchi decided to use "saturation"
dosages of two carotenoids after surgery, both with and without chemotherapy and
radiation, in an effort to prevent the eventual development of a second primary
malignancy. Although only eleven subjects were studied, a survey of these
clinical cases after eight years provided highly promising results. There were
two breast cancers, one lung cancer, five urinary bladder cancers, and three
nose and throat cancers. (24)
The use of saturation dosages of two carotenoids in this
clinical trial, beta-carotene and canthaxanthine, provided total prevention of
second primary tumors far exceeding the expected disease-free intervals for
these cancers. It should also be noted that three of these patients were
initially considered to be hopeless.
Although the Santamaria-Bianchi trial is the first clinical
case report of its kind, the authors report that their convincing results appear
to be confirmed by another case history, which was personally reported to them.
The patient was a middle-aged man who, five and a half years previously,
underwent removal of a kidney due to cancer.
Soon after surgery, dysplasias (precancerous cells) of the
bladder mucosa were detected. The patient began beta-carotene supplementation,
and the abnormal cells completely disappeared after only two months. This tends
to confirm that beta-carotene can prevent the recurrence of cancers that so
often eventually follow surgery.
In their concluding remarks, Santamaria and Bianchi state that
the overall picture emerging from their clinical trials, although preliminary,
is extremely encouraging with regard to current and future intervention trials.
Current Status
A significant body of research shows that beta-carotene can
provide substantial benefit in the prevention and treatment of cancer. It is a
nutritional supplement that is safe, inexpensive, and easy to obtain, and that
does not interfere with any conventional treatments.
Norman I. Krinsky from Tufts University School of Medicine has
researched the beta-carotene-cancer connection extensively. He concludes, "The
implications are obvious: carotenoids may prove to be a very important,
non-toxic chemopreventive agent in the war on human cancer." (12) The research
reviewed in this chapter indicates that beta-carotene may also have a
significant role to play in the treatment of cancer.
Side Effects and Toxicity
Although both vitamin A and beta-carotene have well-documented
anticancer properties, beta-carotene has become the preferred therapeutic
supplement in cancer therapy for several reasons. One of the most important
aspects of treatment with beta-carotene is that it has no known toxicity and
lacks any serious side effects.
Daily high doses of vitamin A can be dangerous, including
damage to the liver and, in extreme cases, death. The side effect of an overdose
of beta-carotene is called carotenosis, which means the skin begins to turn
yellowish-orange, like a carrot. However, this condition is not dangerous.
Dosage
A typical dosage of between 75,000 IU to 150,000 IU of
beta-carotene daily is prescribed for cancer patients at clinics that use
nutritional approaches. This is equivalent to 1 or 2 capsules (25,000 IU each)
at each meal.
I personally take 150,000 IU of beta-carotene daily. From time
to time my patients at the hospital will tease me when my skin color starts to
become yellow-orange. This occasional teasing is my feedback mechanism, which
tells me to decrease my dosage from 150,000 IU daily to 75,000 IU daily for a
few weeks.
However, I want to stress that the slight skin-coloring effect
from high-dose beta-carotene intake is not harmful. It simply means that I have
optimum anticancer protection in all the body's skin and cellular membranes.
En excerpt from the book :
"ALTERNATIVES
IN CANCER THERAPY"
by Ross, R.Ph. Pelton, Lee Overholser
Amazon
Price: $10.40