on the surface, it can look that way. However, look at the adjunct protocol;
* 50 mg Iodoral minimum for Breast Cancer (may start with 12.5 mg).
Some practitioners may recommend another form of Iodine such as Lugol's solution. Iodoral is the Lugol's formula in tablet form especially designed to avoid gastric irritation.
* Vitamin C - 3,000 mg per day (more may be necessary to detox bromide).
* 300-600 mg magnesium oxide or comparable magnesium supplement.
* 200 mcg selenium.
* 500 mg niacin (B3) twice a day. (NOT niacinamide) Start lower to avoid flush.
* 100 mg Vitamin B2 three times a day.
* A comprehensive vitamin and nutrition program.
* (Feb 2008) Dr. Guy Abraham cautions that "excess calcium supplementation
(2,000-3,000 md/day) has been the most common cause of poor response to iodine supplementation." Vitamin Research News Vol. 22. Number 2.
...one realizes the iodine protocol is much more than iodine alone. No element\mineral works alone. The second to last bullet includes "a comprehensive vitamin and nutrition program." I would put the emphasis on "nutrition program"; much easier said than done in this day and age; most people flat out refuse to change diet due, in large part, to social\peer pressures.
The protocol, in other words, is broad spectrum. I suspect most people would be optimum with between 8 and 12 mg a (most) day(s) from primarily food sources. 8 for men, 12 for women. Over time, the needed iodine stores would be replenished. In cases where painful fibrocyctic breasts or cancer were an issue, a more aggressive approach would be needed IMO.
If I were one of the people that experienced a noticeable positive change with the supplementing of iodine and its adjunct protocol, I would not think it over hyped at all... on the other hand, if I had experienced a huge negative result, I would... and I did after a time using Lugol's and Iodoral. Keep in mind here that I, unlike many\most who choose to take up the iodine protocol, did all the cleanses and radically changed my diet well before starting iodine... in addition, I focused on broad spectrum mineral\element replenishment and had been using Laminaria digitata kelp along with dulse, giving me approximately 8 - 12 mg of Iodine a day for about a year and half before starting I... and I had, long before that, always eaten seaweeds in my diet as seaweed soups, sushi, and sashimi, etc. eating it once a week or so; thus my initial Iodine needs likely were not anywhere near what a nutritionally void individual's may be\have been. In addition, I had done a few courses of Edgar Cayce 's I protocol over the previous 20 years.
Even though I no longer supplement as some choose to do (I still take approximately 4 - 12 mg a day in diet through seaweeds etc.), SSKI , Lugol's, Iodoral, and perhaps, soon to be magnascent, are now, what I consider valuable, parts of my "in stock" medical arsenal now... more in preparation of other's needs than for myself as I tend to recognize the need, and very poor diet of most.
While one like yourself, may look at Iodine as over hyped, one must take individual dietary, and environmental exposure history into account before passing judgment.
In addition, many may have issues understanding toxicity vs. Herxheimer.
This is where debate is born... "need" is individually relevant and extremely variable... and who is to say, save for the iodine supplementing individual themselves, who has a FULL understanding, and IS completely honest in their disclosure of, their past and present diet\environmental history, what is toxicity vs. Herxeimer when an obvious problem is realized?
That said, ANYTHING we are exposed to, through diet or environment, including, and possibly especially supplementation, alters our physical chemistry and genetics\DNA.
This is adaptation, polymorphism, pleomorphism, indeed, evolution itself... thus we then pass THE (OUR) changes in our genes - biochemistry onto our children for better or worse.
People need to get to the point (physical and mental health) that they are capable of not only understanding, but comprehending that before they can heal with their mind\spirit alone. Positive thinking will always hasten the healing, or, in some cases, eliminate the problem altogether.
The Iodine protocol is super complicated with emphasis on buying more or less every vitamin/mineral supplement in the market. I have done that. My medicin cabinet was filled with all kinds of vitamins, Vitamin C, B-complex, selenium, Magnesium etc. etc. Its not only complicated, its risky to follow such a protocol.
Besides that, we must remember that there are oxidative therapies ( aka Iodine, H2O2, Ozone ) and then there are anti-oxidative therapies. Both these therapies have the potential of killing bad stuff. But Iodine being a powerful oxidant will cause lot of Oxidative Damage and accelarate aging. Why not try reductive therapies.? I have read about Hydrogen as the most imp. antioxidant.
I have tried Iodine and will be very cautious of it. I do not want accelarated aging. There are enough oxidants, our bodies are already fighting with.
But thanks to the hype and so much lobbying on Iodine, and names associated with a couple of MDs, ppl are falling for Iodine.
VERY TRUE, PEOPLE JUST KEEP SAYIN Iodine IODINE IODINE, BUT iodine causes OXIDATIVE STRESS on the body, THE WORST THING IS THAT PEOPLE RECCOMEND MEGADOSING BLINDLY!
Where do people get all this knowledge on iodine, or do they just repeat it like a PARROT!? NO ACTUAL TESTS DONE?
I tried to mega dose iodine by itself, and It caused me to feel wierd. I bet it was WASTING up my gluthione stores, and causing extra stress to my whole body, and in turn my body was retaining other toxins cos iodine was taking up the gluthione.
AND WHY THE HELL DO PEOPLE MEGADOSE SO MUCH? 50MG WHAT THE HELL? that is soo much?
Wouldnt 1 drop per day sufface? and give the body a gradual non damagin increase in iodine. So many people trying to increase the iodine megadose MORE AND MORE like a bloody COMPATITION... its bloody STUPID!