Probably no one here can tell you for sure why you have liver symptoms. But, what we can tell you is to try doing a few Liver Flushes and see if they help your symptoms. If you get out stones, then you know you should continue flushing. If you get relief of symptoms, then you know you should keep flushing. It is inexpensive to do Liver Flushes and you will never know if they can help until you try them.