Its not for everyone, and it takes some effort to balance faith teaching. I can understand how people new to a church that believes in miracles as normal for the believer would have a lot to adjust to.
I really appreciate that the church you felt drawn out of wasn't a good place. And that anything that reminds you of it feels off. We all have to find our way. And I appreciate you being gracious about Bill and leaving some room for the possibility that he may not be bad.
I guess all I can say is its right for me so far and I doubt that will change at this late point. I am guessing you have found a way of worship that fits for you. As long as it is meeting your needs and helping to equip you to take your place in the kingdom, then that is all there is to say.