You have some good points but any diet which gets results can also influence people who are too easily led
that more of the same is better....
Do not forget that many have tried the carb counting and supplemented diets only to regain more than
the original weight when they fell of the difficult bandwagon.
The secret is in avoiding the REFINED carbs which did not exist in caveman days. Fat cavemen never
had the drive to catch and kill a Mastodon
PS... The NUMBER ONE reason why people live longer NOW is because of Antibiotics
Pasta and bread will kill you if you do not control your intake.
(Watch the fight that this statement starts!)