CureZone
  All Blogs
    Mother Earth Heals

Blog: Mother Earth Heals
by Liora Leah

684 blog entries; 17 entries per page; 1 pages; viewed 1,665,917 times
Description   |   Rules   |   Disclaimer

ADVERTISEMENTS
 
Medianet Ads



ADVERTISEMENTS
 

High Blood Pressure?
3 easy exercises drop blood pressure below 120/80 as soon as today


Eliminate Herpes
Information on the revolutionary Dynamiclear Combat Kit - External & Inter...


Kidney Stones Remedy
Hulda Clark Cleanses




ADVERTISEMENTS
 
Ads from CureZone Sponsors

Is there a Herpes Cure?
There has been a Herpes Treatment Breakthrough


High Blood Pressure?
How 3 easy exercises drop blood pressure below 120/80 as soon as today


14 Liver Cleansing Foods
I would encourage you to incorporate these liver cleanse foods int...


___________

Hulda Clark Cleanses
Wormwood, Clove, Clarkia, Turmeric, Epsom Salt, Uva Ursi, Goldenrod


Free Clark DVD!
Order this free DVD that includes a testimonial by former State Representat...


Liver Cleanse
Eliminate any foreign substances that may be trapped in your liver.


___________

Proven Parasite Diet
The Only Legitimate Diet for Destroying Parasites in 30 Days or Less


Proven Candida Diet
The Only Legitimate Diet for Treating Candida in 30 Days


Oleander Pure Concentrate Capsules
Leukemia and Cancer Immune System Support, 15% Off with ...


Alkaline Water Benefits?
Can you get health benefits from drinking alkaline ionized water? ...


Natural Cancer Remedies


Medically Proven Anti-Cancer Benefits
Medical researchers confirm electrolyzed reduced wate...


Healthy Weight Loss
”After having tried pills, shakes, and about everything else ... I am t...


Royal Tea
”I saw results almost immediately, losing 52 pounds between September and Decembe...


___________

The Best Years in Life
Naturally live longer, healthier and happier and avoid mainstream ma...


Candida Cleanse
The best treatment for Candida.Works fast. Get your health back.Guaranteed ...


The Tesla Shield™
Transformational Technology For Mind Body And Soul.


Lugol’s Iodine Free S&H
J.Crow’s® Lugol’s Iodine Solution. Restore lost reserves.


Become a Sponsor

Monsanto GE Corn Fails

Corn plants are falling over, their roots devastated by a ravenous insect called the corn rootworm. The corn fields are planted with seed engineered by Monsanto precisely to kill the corn rootworm. Monsanto's product known as Bt corn, has failed; rootworms are developing resistance to it.



Date:   12/10/2011 10:50:45 PM   ( 31 mon ) ... viewed 932 times

http://motherjones.com/tom-philpott/2011/12/superinsects-monsanto-corn-epa


Mother Jones Magazine:

Monsanto (Still) Denies Superinsect Problem, Despite Evidence

—By Tom Philpott

| Thu Dec. 8, 2011 4:00 AM PST


http://curezone.com/upload/Members/LioraLeah/rootworm_1.jpg
 corn rootworm: You call it Smartstax, I call it breakfast. imarsman/Flickr

Back in August—as I reported here (1)—something strange began to happen in isolated Iowa corn fields: Otherwise healthy corn plants were falling over, their roots devastated by a ravenous insect called the corn rootworm.

The weird part wasn't pest outbreaks in vast corn fields; farmers know that when you plant a huge amount of land with a single crop, you're also providing a friendly habitat for insects that like to eat that crop. The odd part was that the fields were planted with seed engineered by Monsanto precisely to kill the corn rootworm. Monsanto's product—known as Bt corn—had failed; rootworms were developing resistance to it.

At the time, the EPA—which is responsible for registering pesticide-containing crops like Monsanto's—maintained an icy silence on the matter. But last week, the agency released a report (2) (PDF) that, in calm bureaucratese, rebuked Monsanto for its "inadequate" system for monitoring. It's one of those delectable reports written not by political appointees or higher-ups, but rather by staff scientists reporting what they see. The document offers a fascinating glimpse into the way the agency conducts business with Monsanto.

The report confirmed that resistant rootworms had risen up in four states (Iowa, Minnesota, Illinois, and Nebraska) and suspected in three others (Colorado, South Dakota, and Wisconsin). Now, everyone—Monsanto, the EPA, ag scientists—have known all along that resistance was a danger with Monsanto's rootworm-targeting Bt corn. To avoid resistance, the EPA decreed back in 2003 that farmers using the product had to plant a "refuge" crop of non-Bt corn alongside their Bt corn, so that rootworms that had developed Bt resistance would mate with peers that had not been exposed to it, diluting the resistant trait and keeping it under control.

The question was, how large a refuge? Monsanto, hot to move as much product as possible, wanted to keep it small. In this post from early September (3) I laid out the whole tangled history of how back in 2003, Monsanto strong-armed the EPA into accepting a 20 percent refuge requirement, even after an independent scientific panel convened by the agency had recommended a 50 percent buffer. In a Nature article from the time, available here (4), scientists involved in the panel express rage at the EPA's cave-in.

With this document, the agency is tacitly acknowledging that its independent advisory panel was right, and Monsanto was wrong. What happens now? The Center for Food Safety's Bill Freese points to research from University of Illinois crop scientist Michael Gray suggesting that in some Illinois farm counties, 40 percent of farmers lack access to high-quality non-Bt corn seed. That same problem likely affects farmers throughout the corn belt. Just as farmers have responded to the collapse of Monsanto's Roundup Ready weed-killing technology by dousing their fields with "herbicide cocktails," (5) we'll likely see farmers respond to superinsects with increased doses of toxic insecticides. Beyond that, here are the two takeaways of the EPA's recent bombshell.


• The EPA has been relying on Monsanto to monitor the development of rootworm resistance, and—surprise!—Monsanto has been doing a lousy job of it. When Monsanto hears reports from farmers and seed dealers about possible resistance outbreaks, it's supposed to investigate them. The company's monitoring plan is "inadequate and likely to miss early resistance events," the document states. A less polite but more accurate assessment might be "inadequate and designed to miss early resistance events."

The document lists no fewer than five major problems with Monsanto's monitoring program. The agency notes that when Monsanto gets a report of possibly resistant rootworms, it collects samples of them "within 1-2 miles from neighboring sites of failed fields." That's like a police dispatcher receiving a report of a crime in progress, and sending a cop car within one or two miles of the address. The EPA dryly notes:

Since the majority of adult corn rootworm may not disperse long distances, the greatest probability of capture of resistant genotypes should be in the problem fields, possibly in adjacent fields, but less likely in fields 2 miles away during that particular year.

The document also chides Monsanto for setting the threshold of root damage too high before an investigation is triggered, and thus missing possible early-stage resistance outbreaks that can later break out into large ones.

Perhaps most devastatingly of all, EPA reveals that Monsanto has been receiving reports of possible resistance since 2004—the year after the product's release—when it got 21 such complaints nationwide. The number of reports ballooned to 94 in 2006 and has been hovering at around 100 per year since. And guess what? "Monsanto reported that none of their follow-up investigations resulted…in finding resistant populations [of rootworms]."

In other words, to hear Monsanto tell it, resistance isn't a problem at all! And since Monsanto is responsible for monitoring it, the public would not know about the problem if an independent scientist, Iowa State University entomologist Aaron Gassmann, hadn't published a paper documenting four cases of it in Iowa in August, prompting a major story in the Wall Street Journal (6)

Monsanto responded to Grossman's findings with brazen denial: "We don't have any demonstrated field resistance," a Monsanto official insisted to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch (7) when asked about the study. As recently as last week, in the wake of the EPA document's release, Monsanto officials continued to assert that there had been no scientific confirmation of resistance to its Bt corn, Bloomberg reported (8). The response calls to mind the old Groucho Marx joke about the man pleading with his wife after being caught in flagrante with another woman: "Who are you going to believe: me, or your lying eyes?"

Monsanto's denial calls to mind the old joke about the man caught in flagrante by his wife: "Who are you going to believe: me, or your lying eyes?"• Monsanto is already peddling a solution to the problem it generated—and it, too, looks vulnerable to resistance. Now, even though Monsanto has so far refused to acknowledge the resistance problem, the company has not shied away from promoting its new "Smartstax" corn seeds, which contain the current failing Bt toxin plus another that it has licensed from its rival, Dow, as a remedy. Bloomberg reports:

Farmers with root damage in their fields should consider changing practices to "stay ahead of this insect," Monsanto said in a statement. That could include rotating corn with soybeans or using a product such as Monsanto's SmartStax corn, which kills rootworms with two types of Bt, the company said.

Because it contains two separate rootworm-attacking pesticides, Monsanto insists that Smartstax is less prone to cause resistance and thus needs an even smaller refuge area. The company has persuaded the EPA to require only a 5 percent refuge for Smartstax, leaving the other 95 percent open for Monsanto's business.

But in its memo from last week, EPA scientists bluntly question the wisdom of that approach. With one of its Bt toxins having already lost effectiveness, the report notes, Smartstax will be "substantially less durable" when planted with just a 5 percent refuge, and it "could ultimately compromise the second unrelated toxin used to control the pest." In other words, the debut of Smartstax will likely delay, but not stop, the march of Bt-resistant superinsects. But putting off problems by forever rolling out profitable new "solutions" is precisely the agrichemical industry's business model (9).

The question now is, will the EPA's decision makers heed this bombshell of a report and start actually subjecting Monsanto to independent oversight? Of course, as for those ravenous corn rootworms squirming around the Midwest, the solution is simple: The Union of Concerned Scientist's Doug Gurian-Sherman has said it before (10) and he said it again this week (11): Just stop growing so much damn corn. Simple biodiversity in farm fields, it turns out, trumps the latest patented geegaw conjured up by Monsanto. And it also makes for a healthier food supply.

Tom Philpott is the food and ag blogger for Mother Jones. For more of his stories, click here:  http://motherjones.com/authors/tom-philpott

 

Get Tom Philpott's RSS feed: http://motherjones.com/rss/authors/116126

Links to this article:

(1) Attack of the Monsanto SuperInsects:
http://motherjones.com/tom-philpott/2011/08/monsanto-gm-super-insects


(2) https://motherjones.com/files/epa-hq-opp-2011-0922-0003.pdf


(3)Monsanto Denies SuperInsect Science http://motherjones.com/tom-philpott/2011/09/monsanto-denies-superinsect-science


(4) http://www.gene.ch/genet/2003/May/msg00066.html  

 
(5)Monsanto's "Superweeds" Gallop Through Midwest
http://motherjones.com/tom-philpott/2011/07/monsanto-superweeds-roundup


(6)Monsanto Corn Plant Losing Bug Resistance
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424053111904009304576532742267732046.html


(7) Monsanto BioTech Corn Not Killing Pests

http://www.stltoday.com/business/local/article_48721bc6-38cb-5cf0-aae1-2b1a7e...


(8) Monsanto Corn May Be Failing to Kill Bugs, EPA Says http://mobile.bloomberg.com/news/2011-12-01/monsanto-corn-may-be-failing-to-k...

(9) How the Agrichemical Industry turns Failure into Market Opportunity http://www.grist.org/article/How-the-agrichemical-industry-turns-failure-into...

(10) Engineered Pest Problems http://blog.ucsusa.org/engineered-pest-problems

(11) Is This Sustainable Agriculture? Resistance to Engineered Bt Corn on the Rise http://blog.ucsusa.org/is-this-sustainable-agriculture-resistance-to-engineer...



 

Add This Entry To Your CureZone Favorites!

Printer-friendly version of this page
Email this message to a friend
Bookmark this page/Add to Favorites or press Ctrl+D
DISCLAIMER / WARNING   Alert Webmaster



Share:  Facebook  MySpace  Digg  Reddit  StumbleUpon  Furl this page  Delicious  BlinkList  dzone  Simpy.com  Fark.com  BlogMarks  Wists.com  Google

Add This Blog To Your CureZone Favorites!
 
Add This Entry To Your CureZone Favorites!

Comments (25 of 479):
Re: Organic Batter… Liora… 19 d
Re: Organic Batter… Desti… 19 d
Re: Chemicals Maki… Liora… 6 mon
Re: Chemicals Maki… zincs… 13 mon
Re: Photos:Human C… Liora… 17 mon
Re: Photos:Human C… Milla… 17 mon
Re: Photos:Human C… Liora… 17 mon
Re: Environmental … Liora… 27 mon
Re: Environmental … Liora… 27 mon
Re: Environmental … mu-sh… 27 mon
Re:1 million page … Liora… 29 mon
Re:1 million page … YOURE… 29 mon
Re: Occupy Tokyo--… YOURE… 30 mon
Re: What are you B… Liora… 31 mon
What are you BEING? Liora… 31 mon
Re: No More Corpo… ruden… 32 mon
Re: This is, I sup… Liora… 32 mon
This is, I suppose… mu-sh… 32 mon
oops!Sorry!Mistake! Liora… 3 y
Re: Styrofoam Alt… Liora… 3 y
Re: Styrofoam Alt… Liora… 3 y
Re: Styrofoam Alt… ren 3 y
Re: Thank you for … YOURE… 3 y
Re: Sungazing/Bare… Liora… 3 y
Re: Sungazing/Bare… lovel… 3 y
All Comments (479)

Blog Entries (12 of 684):
Monsanto GE Corn Fails  31 mon
Help Somali Refugees  31 mon
Portable Solar Light!  31 mon
Gift to the Earth  31 mon
Buy Nothing Day!11/25-26/2011  32 mon
No More Corporate Greed!  32 mon
Give for FREE!  3 y
Reusable Pizza Box  3 y
Styrofoam Alternative  3 y
MCS:Homesick, the Video  3 y
Child's Poem  3 y
Photo:Stunning Saturn  3 y
All Entries (684)

Blogs by Liora Leah (1):
Spirit Speaks  30 mon  (256)

Similar Blogs (10 of 185):
Plant Your Dream!  by YourEnchantedGardener  3 h
Psyche & Health  by Chef JeM  9 h
Ya’ think??  by kerminator  41 h
Cheeta: Cultural He…  by Chef JeM  5 d
america ferrera wei…  by goldbearg  5 d
ShinyLife  by Sacristia  7 d
Homeopathic Medicin…  by bhargavphytolab  7 d
Healthy Sexual Life  by EleS  13 d
the struggle  by kikicoca  18 d
Alkaline Water Theo…  by Destinycurez  19 d
All Blogs (1,019)


Liver Cleanse
Hulda Clark Liver Cleanse

Back To Top

Selected Ads from CureZone Sponsors: Become a Sponsor

VIP

All Natural Colon Cleanse
Refresh & Detoxify Your Body Fast. Clean Your Colon The Healthy Way...
Herpes Cure?
Herpes Treatment Breakthrough
Reverse Type 2 Diabetes
In 3 simple steps, she nails what no one wants to reveal how type 2 d...
 
 

PLAT

Oxy-Powder® Colon Cleanse
All Natural Oxygen Cleanser. Rated Best Product Line by NaturalNews...
Clarkia Parasites Cleanse
Clarkia Tincture 2 oz, 4 oz, 8 oz, and 16 oz
Free Clark DVD!
Bestselling author Dr. Hulda Clark claims to have cured cancer
 
 

GOLD

Proven medical anti-diabetic benefits
Electrolyzed drinking water significantly reduces blood...
Proven Candida Diet
The Only Legitimate Diet for Treating Candida in 30 Days
Utopia Silver Supplements
Enhance Nutrient Absorption with Digestive Enzymes- Bromelain, Enzy...
Proven Parasite Diet
The Only Legitimate Diet for Destroying Parasites in 30 Days or Less
 
 

GOLD

Royal Tea
”Not only did Royal Tea make me look years younger, I feel years younger too.” - Sa...
Detoxify and Cleanse Naturally
Drink ionized alkaline waters medically proven health benefits...
Get an Instant Discount!
Get 5% off anything in our homeopathic health store using the coupon...
Natural Cancer Remedies
 
 

SILVER

Lugol’s Iodine Free S&H
J.Crow’s® Lugol’s Iodine Solution. Restore lost reserves.
Best Candida Treatment
Ccws™ Works Fast To Get Rid Of Candida.Feel Healthy.Money Back Guarant...
The Tesla Shield™
Transformational Technology For Mind Body And Soul.
Good Health Naturally
The best in digestive enzymes, serrapeptase, krill oil, olive leaf extr...
 
 
Back To Top How many people click on the sponsord links? Become a Sponsor



 


Guest Book - Liver Flush FAQ - News - Link Exchange - Add URL - How To Exchange Links? - About Global Directory

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Spam Policy - Disclaimer - Guidelines & Rules - Forum Trolls - Fair use notice

Staff's pages:  Owen - Wrenn - Maya


CureZone Newsletter is distributed in partnership with www.netatlantic.com


Contact Us - About - Donors - Stats



Copyright 2014  curezone.com


fetched in 0.51 sec at 7/29/2014 1:52:08 PM, requested by 54.196.189.229, referred by http://curezone.com/blogs/fm.asp?i=1889823 , requested 1 pages during this session, y=2